Having spent time working with the Wiimote as a software developer for a research institution, and realizing just how great a tool it is for presentations, I had been anticipating a similar tool from Microsoft. One that I could use for applications such as a great presentation mouse replacement, and a remote tracking device for medical modeling. Now that I have seen what project Natal from Microsoft is, I have to say that while it is cool, I am disappointed.
Microsoft claims that the Wiimote is only a transitional step to what they think is the next best thing [1] IE project Natal.
I say they jumped over a critical step.
Not all situations will be conducive to the natal device. There will be some situations where a hand held pointer like the Wiimote will work better.
For example: if you are using the natal device in front of an audience and the camera also picks up the audience, how efficient (fast) will the natal device be at filtering out the movements of the people behind you? If you are using a Wiimote the Wiimote will not get confused in this situation and thus not lose precious computing cycles filtering unwanted data. Beyond that, I think the Natal device is really cool. I just want my cake while I eat it.
Now if only we could get Nintendo to allow us easy simple access to the Wiimote via a PC by providing us with a decent standardized device driver like Microsoft does, instead of having to rely on a Rube Goldberg non-standard Bluetooth protocol connection process that does not always work.
Or maybe some other third party can do it for us. Hey Logitech!
Copyright 2009 William T. Richards